
Corporate holding companies often assume that their accounting firms automatically cover all subsidiaries-but this assumption can expose them to significant legal risks. A growing number of states have enacted statutory privity requirements that bar all claims asserted by parties lacking a direct contractual relationship. Without explicit naming in engagement letters, subsidiaries may face a locked courthouse door if errors or misrepresentations occur.
The core issue revolves around privity, a legal principle stating that only parties with a direct contract can enforce professional services. Courts applying these statutes generally bar claims absent direct privity or specific knowledge that the work was intended to benefit or influence the claimant.
Subsidiaries face two key disadvantages without a contract. First, they lose access to longer statutes of limitation tied to written agreements. Second, accounting firms can dismiss claims at the earliest stages by arguing no duty was owed. Courts have repeatedly sided with firms when subsidiaries weren’t named, even when the work clearly benefited them.
This risk is not theoretical. In New Jersey, a court dismissed a claim against Ernst & Young because the subsidiary wasn’t listed in the engagement letter, despite the firm’s audit directly affecting its financial statements. Similarly, in Michigan, investors lost their case when they weren’t identified as intended beneficiaries in writing.
Many corporate counsel only recognize this issue after a dispute arises. The solution is clear: engagement letters must explicitly name every subsidiary, with acknowledgments that each has independent standing to enforce the agreement. Generic references to “affiliates” or “related entities” are insufficient. The letter—or an attached schedule—should list each entity by its full legal name and state that the firm’s duties extend to all of them.
How to Update Letters for New Subsidiaries
Third, when a subsidiary is formed or acquired, amend the engagement letter or execute a supplemental letter by name. A clause naming “future subsidiaries” may help, but enforceability varies, so the safest practice is a contemporaneous update. Counsel should not assume that a future-subsidiary provision automatically creates duties to an entity formed later. The safest approach is to add each new entity by name and confirm the firm’s acknowledgment of its duties.
In-house counsel and board members overseeing companies with engagement letters that omit subsidiaries should: (1) audit all current engagement letters with accounting and other professional firms; (2) identify every subsidiary or affiliate not named as a party; (3) direct the relationship partner or firm administrator to execute an amendment adding each omitted entity and acknowledging independent duties to it; (4) present any refusal to the board as a risk factor in evaluating the relationship; and (5) adopt a policy requiring new subsidiaries to be added within thirty days of formation or acquisition, with compliance reported through regular governance review.
Regular reviews of these agreements can prevent litigation risks before they materialize. The cost of updating a few letters is minimal compared to the potential liability of leaving a subsidiary unprotected. For companies with complex structures, this is a straightforward way to ensure no entity is left without recourse.
Related Post: Misdiagnosis: Legal Recourse for Patients Against Medical Errors
State Laws Tighten Privity Requirements Further
However, firms often argue that their duty runs solely to the contracting party. In Rosenblum, Inc. v. Adler, the New Jersey Supreme Court allowed a claim against an accountant because the firm knew its work would be used by the plaintiff, but the decision depended on specific evidence of intent, not a blanket assumption. Other states, such as Wisconsin and Missouri, apply a “balancing test,” evaluating whether the harm was foreseeable and whether the accountant’s conduct directly led to the injury. Without a written contract, subsidiaries must prove these elements in court, a process that is both costly and unpredictable.
To address the uncertainty of common law, many states have enacted statutes explicitly requiring privity or written confirmation of intended beneficiaries. Louisiana’s Accountancy Act (La. Rev. Stat. § 37:91) bars claims unless the accountant knew the work was intended to benefit a specific party, or, in some cases, unless the accountant provided written confirmation to the non-client. Similar laws exist in Arkansas, Illinois, Kansas, Michigan, New Jersey, Utah, and Wyoming. These statutes impose a strict burden: even if a subsidiary suffered damages due to an accountant’s negligence, the absence of a direct contract or written acknowledgment can defeat the claim at the outset.
Illinois has particularly strict requirements. Under 225 Ill. Comp. Stat. Ann. 450/30.1, an accountant must not only know that its work was intended to benefit a third party but also must explicitly name that party in writing and send confirmation to the intended beneficiary. In Freeman, Freeman and Salzman, P.C. v. Lipper, the Illinois Appellate Court allowed a claim because the accountant’s reports were directly addressed to the plaintiffs. However, in Yadlosky v. Grant Thornton, a Michigan federal court dismissed a case where investors were not specifically identified in writing, despite the firm’s awareness of their reliance. These rulings demonstrate that statutory privity requirements are not mere technicalities; they are enforceable defenses that can bar recovery entirely.
Kansas and Utah impose similar restrictions. Kansas law (Kan. Stat. Ann. § 1-402) requires written identification of intended beneficiaries, while Utah’s statute (Utah Code Ann. § 58-26a-602) aligns with Louisiana’s approach, demanding knowledge of the beneficiary’s reliance. Critics argue these provisions create a “locked courthouse door” for injured parties, particularly when accountants refuse to amend engagement letters retroactively. Without proactive measures, subsidiaries risk having their claims dismissed before litigation even begins.
Even when common law or statutory privity does not bar a claim outright, the absence of a contract forces subsidiaries into tort claims, which carry shorter statutes of limitations. In New York, contract claims have a six-year limit (N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 213(2)), while tort claims are limited to three years (N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 214(6)). Civ. Proc. Code § 337(1)) and two years for tort claims (Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 339(1)). These time constraints can be fatal for subsidiaries that discover accounting errors years later, perhaps during an IRS audit, a merger, or the preparation of restated financial statements.
Courts Often Side With Firms Without Contracts
Accounting firms may argue that their professional duties extend only to the entity named in the engagement letter, leaving subsidiaries without legal recourse. Courts in multiple jurisdictions have upheld this position, dismissing claims from entities not explicitly identified as parties to the contract. Some states apply a balancing test to determine whether a duty arose, considering factors like the intended effect of the engagement, foreseeability of harm, and the connection between the firm’s conduct and the injury suffered. However, even under this approach, firms often prevail when no direct contractual relationship exists.
Subsidiaries without named status in engagement letters face shorter statutes of limitations for recovery, typically two to three years for tort claims compared to four to six years for contract-based claims. Errors in financial statements or tax filings may not surface until years later, such as during an IRS audit, a transaction review, or the release of restated financials. Without privity, subsidiaries may lose the opportunity to pursue claims under the longer contractual period, increasing the risk of time-barred litigation.
This includes accounting, audit, tax, and other professional service agreements. If gaps are found, firms should be directed to amend the letters to include all current and future subsidiaries, with explicit acknowledgment of duties owed to each. Failure to address these gaps may later be treated as a governance oversight in the event of malpractice claims.
Leave a Reply