
A recent program at the ABA Business Law Section’s 2026 Fall Meeting in Chicago, titled “2025 Commercial Law Developments,” highlighted the importance of security agreements in commercial law. The program featured three panelists, including Teresa Harmon, Steven Weise, and Stephen L. Sepinuck, special UCC advisor at Paul Hastings LLP and adjunct professor at University of Maine School of Law, who presented notable decisions in secured transactions and commercial finance from the past year.
Harmon emphasized that a security agreement works like a Chicago hot dog, which requires seven specific toppings-skip one, and it isn’t a Chicago dog. She noted that missing one required element in a security agreement can put the security interest at risk.
The panel reviewed several cases, including Winner Circle Imports, LLC v. Whitney’s Automotive Venture Enterprise, LLC, which involved an asset purchase agreement that stated the buyer’s obligations “shall be secured by a perfected lien” in an LLC’s membership interests. The court held that this language did not constitute a present grant, and therefore, no security interest was created.
Security Agreement Requirements
Harmon advised that when using a form from a prior deal, it is important to review the grant and ensure it reads as a present grant. She also discussed the case of County Federal Credit Union v. Madore, in which the borrower signed the first page of the loan package, which stated, “You are giving a security interest in… the property described below.” Although the borrower did not sign at the end of the security agreement section, the Maine Supreme Judicial Court held that the signed page was sufficient.
However, Harmon noted that the better approach is to get every signature block signed. The security agreement must describe the collateral, and two cases illustrated this issue from opposite directions. In In re Payroll Management, Inc., the Eleventh Circuit held that a security agreement covering contracts did not specifically describe commercial tort claims, as required by Article 9.
Another case, Cannon v. Romeo Systems, Inc., involved a pledge agreement that described “a warrant to purchase . . . one million shares,” but the warrant was actually for 1 percent of the corporation’s outstanding shares. The Court of Chancery found the description inadequate, but the Delaware Supreme Court reversed, holding that the description only needs to be reasonable.
Related Post: German court weighs war crimes case over Nord Stream sabotage
Ownership and Authority
A fine-art case, August Uribe Fine Art, LLC v. Dartmilano SRL, demonstrated that the debtor must own the collateral. In this case, a Picasso painting sold through an auction house went to a storage company, but the court held that the buyer did not own it because delivery had not been made.
Weise noted that checking ownership is where the client’s due diligence comes in, as most personal property has no title registry. The person signing the security agreement must also have authority. In Canon Advance, LLC v. DG Midwest, LLC, an individual signed a merchant cash advance security agreement on behalf of an LLC. Sepinuck explained that membership alone does not give the signer actual authority, and the agreement’s own statement of authority cannot create apparent authority. Sepinuck explained that apparent authority must come from the principal, and he used the example of claiming to be an agent of Microsoft or Meta without actually being one.
The panelists also discussed the importance of filing and enforcing security agreements correctly. In PJ Visionary Pte. Ltd. v. Five Senses LLC, a lender filed only against the parent company, not its subsidiaries, resulting in unperfected assets. Weise noted that these problems are basic and continue to arise despite being discussed every year.
The year’s cases highlight the importance of getting the basics right in security agreements, including writing the grant in the present tense, describing the collateral reasonably, and confirming ownership and authority. As the panelists noted, these are not hard problems, but rather basic mistakes that can be avoided with careful attention to detail.
Best Practices for Security Agreements
The program featured a checklist of key takeaways: Write the grant in the present tense and get every signature block signed. Confirm the debtor owns what it pledges and confirm the signer’s authority. File against every debtor entity, under its correct name. The panelists noted that security agreements only work when every required element is present, and skipping one can risk the security interest.
The Uniform Commercial Code Committee and the Commercial Finance Committee co-sponsored the program, which was presented as on-demand CLE, free for Business Law Section members.
Leave a Reply