Breaking
Bench Verdicts

Slush Puppie Legal Battle Ends with Fraud Finding

By Valentina Romero 3 min read
Slush Puppie Legal Battle Ends with Fraud Finding - slush-puppie legal battle
Slush Puppie Limited and Icee Co. relied on two separate contracts to operate across Europe and the United Kingdom.

When international deals go cold, the results can be as frozen as the beverage at the center of a seven-year legal battle. Slush Puppie Ltd. v. Icee Co. turned a dispute over a frozen drink franchise into a case study in how poorly drafted manufacturing and distribution agreements can complicate cross-border intellectual property enforcement. The conflict centered on the gap between the rights actually granted and the rights the parties later claimed, creating a complex web of overlapping contracts that eventually collapsed into millions in damages.

Two Agreements, Overlapping Rights

Slush Puppie Limited and Icee Co. relied on two separate contracts to operate across Europe and the United Kingdom. In 1996, Icee granted Slush Puppie Limited an exclusive manufacturing appointment across twenty-seven European countries. A 1999 Distributor Agreement later granted the rights to distribute Slush Puppie and use the SLUSH PUPPIE marks exclusively in the United Kingdom and Ireland. Because the later agreement did not replace the earlier manufacturing contract, both remained operative until Icee terminated them in June 2019.

The contractual limits on Slush Puppie’s European distribution and trademark rights became a persistent source of commercial friction. That friction intensified when Slush Puppie relied on a fabricated 2000 appointment purporting to grant exclusive European trademark rights while separately contending that an earlier agreement had reduced its royalty obligation from 5% to 2.5%. In hindsight, asserting broader European rights alongside a 50% royalty reduction should have raised an immediate red flag.

Termination and the Trial

Few provisions proved more consequential than the 1999 agreement’s termination clause triggered by litigation. Once the dispute moved to court, Slush Puppie challenged the litigation-triggered provisions as unconscionable, but the court rejected the argument. The judge emphasized the parties’ commercial sophistication, their long-standing voluntary dealings, and the agreement’s distinction between curable defaults and events permitting immediate termination.

Related Post: German court strengthens privacy rights over Google Earth images

Once litigation began, the case became far more than a contractual dispute. Judge Barrett ultimately dismissed Slush Puppie’s remaining claims with prejudice for the fraud perpetrated on the court and the American judicial process. As of publication, a federal jury in Ohio had also returned an advisory verdict in Icee’s favor on its counterclaims, finding unjust enrichment, trademark infringement under sections 10(1) and 10(3) of the U.K. Trade Marks Act 1994, and passing off under U.K. common law.

The jury allocated $33 million in disgorgement across post-termination periods from 2019 through 2025, with separate disgorgement awards totaling $3.6 million on the U.K. trademark and passing-off claims. This outcome highlights the risks inherent in international licensing when the governing documents fail to clearly delineate territory, ownership, and the mechanics of winding up the relationship.

Lessons from Slush Puppie

When commercializing intellectual property abroad, it is essential to draft manufacturing and distribution agreements from the end backward, addressing termination and winding up from the outset. The agreements should clearly address term, territory, exclusivity, intellectual property ownership and enforcement, performance and review milestones, royalty rates, termination, governing law, forum selection, and post-termination obligations. In the Slush Puppie case, the parties’ failure to clearly define these terms led to a prolonged and costly dispute.

Legal Basis and Procedural History

The court referenced statutes and the Berne Convention as part of the legal framework for IP protection and redress. The proceedings included challenges to the authenticity of a purported 2000 appointment.

Valentina Romero

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *